Big Brother Award: Telekom Austria wins popular vote
Telekom Austria wins popular vote
The "People's Choice" won the Telekom Austria victory for the sharing of customer data to the porn industry: The rampant in Germany, warning wave - in the last Year, was cited for matching estimates, about 150,000 people for alleged infringement of copyright - has spilled over in the fall of 2008 to Austria. At the request of a Vorarlberg law firm that was commissioned by porn companies operate, gave the Telekom Austria on the personal data of customers of hundreds of broadband connections.
Telekom Austria relied only on the legal situation: According to the Supreme Court's decision one is obliged to surrender copyright infringement master data and IP addresses of customers. Neither the Association of Internet Providers [ISPA] nor the competitors of the TA - all the others - make this legal opinion, a condition of data transfer is for them still the decision of the court. That even with the TA from its own legal opinion was not really confident that proves the pivotal: after vociferous protests from the customers, the data transmission stopped.
Telekom Austria for porn data-sharing awards
Telekom Austria, the security spokesman for the ÖVP and the SPÖ or the post office, all of them on Saturday evening in the Viennese theater Rabenhof the "Big Brother Award" given. With this award, people, government, institutions and companies to be considered, dealing in "Big Brother" style little creditable to personal data. ...
Telekom Malaysia: customer data for the porn industry
The rampant in Germany, warning wave - in the last year, according to the matching estimates, about 150,000 people was cited for alleged infringement of copyright - has spilled over in the fall of 2008 to Austria. At the request of a Vorarlberg law firm that was commissioned by porn companies operate, gave the Telekom Austria on the personal data of customers of hundreds of broadband connections. In hard on threat warnings formulated asked you a flat fee of 800 € for downloading "of copyrighted works" rights holders such as "Cazzo Film" or "pussy movie" belongs. Telekom Austria relied only on the legal situation: According to Supreme Court decision-one was obliged to surrender copyright infringement master data and IP addresses of customers. Neither the Association of Internet Providers [ISPA], or the competitors of the TA - all the others - make this legal opinion, condition for the transfer of data is still liable to the decision of the court. That one also in the TA from its own legal opinion was not really convinced, prove the swing: after vociferous protests from the customers, the data transmission stopped. pass to the original decision, so their customers' data at all and may have voluntarily contributed, first: Per request on behalf of "pussy movie" and Co was the same Fee charged, which is levied according to Regulation for court-ordered monitoring. They are around 100 €, 800 € for the required is a cut of 12.5 percent per case and overall a nice Körberlgeld *, especially since the entire effort is a simple database query. Why Deutsche Telekom, second, not against a media company, but to porn Winzlingsfirmen has become weak, also fits into the picture. From a myriad of relevant fraud - Accounting without power and other rip-offs - it is known that the victims pay implicit in the rule, because want to have publicly named in connection with porn no one's name. [Körberlgeld = extra money]
Saturday, October 25, 2008
Friday, October 17, 2008
Kate Playground Western
Other press reports + Information Stop
Note: Of course, further action by the Law Firm LF unknown. This story is going to have a sequel, and / or go in a different way on.
data transfer to adult industry: Telekom Austria provides information a
company's response to reporting - No passing on more of master data - seems Controversial warning wave initially stopped
Telekom fell Austria quickly under fire after derStandard.at and reported other Austrian media was that the company had during the warning wave of the porn industry, where customer information. The company was based on this the legal situation, which must be granted without a court order for copyright infringement information. With the changes
10.17.2008 Austria's largest Internet providers now his actions and stop with all the information about master data of users.
could Earlier, Steffen Hein Cz see this article again: porn industry is planning action against Austrians
already hundreds of home sharers of warning wave hit - gave Telekom Austria on user data - - Claims at 800 € per case of copyright infringement on with reminder letter Download
Today, tomorrow: Tele2 and UPC No user data gave further
Two of the three largest local Internet provider to stress no user data to the porn industry to have passed - "Not without a court order"
Der Spiegel [one format for most of the mirror] hats and : Austrian Telekom Gunock apparently porn downloader
just confirmed the information ORF stop.
I hope The retrieval of consumer protection, etc. are ashamed Angle Gene awareness and track now accordingly.
Note: Of course, further action by the Law Firm LF unknown. This story is going to have a sequel, and / or go in a different way on.
data transfer to adult industry: Telekom Austria provides information a
company's response to reporting - No passing on more of master data - seems Controversial warning wave initially stopped
Telekom fell Austria quickly under fire after derStandard.at and reported other Austrian media was that the company had during the warning wave of the porn industry, where customer information. The company was based on this the legal situation, which must be granted without a court order for copyright infringement information. With the changes
10.17.2008 Austria's largest Internet providers now his actions and stop with all the information about master data of users.
could Earlier, Steffen Hein Cz see this article again: porn industry is planning action against Austrians
already hundreds of home sharers of warning wave hit - gave Telekom Austria on user data - - Claims at 800 € per case of copyright infringement on with reminder letter Download
Today, tomorrow: Tele2 and UPC No user data gave further
Two of the three largest local Internet provider to stress no user data to the porn industry to have passed - "Not without a court order"
Der Spiegel [one format for most of the mirror] hats and : Austrian Telekom Gunock apparently porn downloader
just confirmed the information ORF stop.
I hope The retrieval of consumer protection, etc. are ashamed Angle Gene awareness and track now accordingly.
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Free Invitation Dedication Of Baby Cards
press release Längle - Format
users of the Internet-sharing network eDonkey are covered by a firm with more aggressive warnings of Vorarlberg. Their clients: German porn film producers, their Infringing the copyrights of view. According FORMAT research concerning this warning wave only Telekom Austria customers. Short [ click here to read more about the topic ]
Note: You can see the dürrfen are my opinions certainly enjoy a degree of confirmation. Barbara Mayer of an express thanks for this very unique and journalistic quality crafted items. [... I have to do with nothing left.]
users of the Internet-sharing network eDonkey are covered by a firm with more aggressive warnings of Vorarlberg. Their clients: German porn film producers, their Infringing the copyrights of view. According FORMAT research concerning this warning wave only Telekom Austria customers. Short [ click here to read more about the topic ]
Note: You can see the dürrfen are my opinions certainly enjoy a degree of confirmation. Barbara Mayer of an express thanks for this very unique and journalistic quality crafted items. [... I have to do with nothing left.]
Saturday, October 11, 2008
Men Dressing In Ladies Underwear
updates week 41
New statistical assessment.
attorney recommendation
light changed detes modiifizierten pattern of a cease and desist letter
- by registered letter -
LF-LAW
Längle Fussenegger Singer
Legal Partnership
A - This 6900 Bregenz
Bross Waldgasse 12
desist
I undertake to
Mr / Ms ____________________________,
(first name / last name )
____________________________________,
(road)
___________,________________________,
(zip code, city)
____________________________________,
(reference)
me without acknowledging any legal obligation to do so and without prejudice to the factual and legal nevertheless legally binding, to the company
INO trade GmbH, Otto-Hahn-Str. 15, D - failed to help,
all copyrighted works of cinematic art of omission creditor without the consent of omission creditor, in particular through public provision, as defined in § 14 of the Copyright Act to recover - 42369 Wuppertal,
- hereinafter "omission creditor referred .
I give off this cease and desist letter, subject to the condition that the legal action to be refrained from as a result of a legislative amendment or revision of the Supreme Court, is.
___________________
place, date
___________________ Signature of Abgemahnt
Use at your own risk.
New statistical assessment.
attorney recommendation
light changed detes modiifizierten pattern of a cease and desist letter
- by registered letter -
LF-LAW
Längle Fussenegger Singer
Legal Partnership
A - This 6900 Bregenz
Bross Waldgasse 12
desist
I undertake to
Mr / Ms ____________________________,
(first name / last name )
____________________________________,
(road)
___________,________________________,
(zip code, city)
____________________________________,
(reference)
me without acknowledging any legal obligation to do so and without prejudice to the factual and legal nevertheless legally binding, to the company
INO trade GmbH, Otto-Hahn-Str. 15, D - failed to help,
all copyrighted works of cinematic art of omission creditor without the consent of omission creditor, in particular through public provision, as defined in § 14 of the Copyright Act to recover - 42369 Wuppertal,
- hereinafter "omission creditor referred .
I give off this cease and desist letter, subject to the condition that the legal action to be refrained from as a result of a legislative amendment or revision of the Supreme Court, is.
___________________
place, date
___________________ Signature of Abgemahnt
Use at your own risk.
Friday, October 3, 2008
What Color Acute Hiv Rash
facts KW40
Introduction
since August of 2008, the I designed webblog [ link ] and another German information page [ link ] a growing number of Austrian citizens who are on these pages about the topic " warnings from German porn producer in Austria by the firm Längle + Fussenegger, Bregenz ", provide in the short follow-LF-called Law. Justified the claims in the letters made claims with alleged violations of exploitation films from the producers in the so-called P2P file sharing, particularly in the so-called emule2000 network. The known details are now presented in abbreviated form. The result after two months is sobering: As there of the parties concerned failed a united front against the most absurd and illegal hardly produce about bidding processes and to the attorney area into serious qualitative deficiencies are noted, this report will necessarily depend on the competent authorities sent, which are hereby invited for an immediate halt to the activities of all participants to clarify to ensure the situation before OHG. The clarification of the legal situation is dealt with by a State, as the as the only "data merchants" in Austria Telekom Austria is occurring Provider absolutely overwhelmed with this task. Since it is already collected and Researched amounts of data involved would have no effect of this approach in the field of other possible civil prosecution. For immediate comments would be appreciated. In part, be suspicious given the lead in police investigations can and a "test complaint" is set. A general statement of the competent Bar Association is urgently required. Please send the documents entsprehenden at the end of the address. Please note: all the answers, no answers will be published. Standing
this, the reference, which is not the pursuit of copyright infringement on the Internet by Austrian prosecutors the subject of this report, but the manner of the approach is criticized. The tendency of the authors of the report, the development in Germany considers exemplary. The division of the offenses with minor cases in the claim limits and by judges decision established, commercially oriented types of injuries would be useful to medium term for Austria. In this respect, this is also the chance of the result of the enormous to develop chaotic development of the affair following a solid solution for the future. The report, in which about put 170 hours of work goes, the Austrian taxpayers free of charge and is solely the personal opinions of the blog owner dar.
Systematic Abmahntätigkeit
As the firm's clients LF-Law are satisfied that: INO GmbH, Wuppertal + Hustler Europe GmbH, Krefeld + GMV GmbH & Co. KG, Ochsenburg + SG Video GmbH, Germany [Z-factor media Illertissen] + BBVideo GmbH, Duisburg + Cazzo GmbH, Berlin + Tino Media, Berlin + Cyber Net GmbH, Offenbach.
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit by AZ packages
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit to monthly data, and be warned households
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit after warnings Shual blog with comparative value Pásah blog [name changed for security reasons] and maximum value
explanation of the graphs: From database records, current AZ-number, track data and comparative data from Germany, a conservative holding the average can be achieved. The real figure is double the area. Basically, many households receive multiple warnings, so that should the above data [Chart 2] are multiplied by a factor of 2. One determined by a Qualifying statement of a competent technician to Datenaufbearbeitung Telekom Austria confirms over "several hundred" requests to 09/20/2008 the previous image. [Note: All personal statements in this report can by the author in this report in writing and verified by specific names and addresses. See item: "influence". To clarify the data and other information in the report satisfies the requirement of a public body to give the system of inquiry. Personal information may be processed only on request.] According to the current situation can be up to date at the end of week 40 with a total 1540 warnings be expected, which can be estimate to a claim amount of approximately € 1.2 million. The "potential" for 2008 is estimated at approximately € 3.7 million, these sums are still able to increase greatly. [See Ad volume alone in the district of the General Prosecutor Hamm, Germany, first semester, for the same individual claim amount: € 27.6 million] According to [warning, if necessary: see Appendix], the LF-Law shall be informed by the end KW40 well over € 0.2 million to Telekom Austria removed as Ausfwandsentschädigung. The "potential" for 2008 is € 0.5 million. The economic losses [consumer protection, telecoms, legal fees, Consumption losses, debt, etc.] is consistently on the same level as the claim amount. There may be only one law firm is currently active and organized predictable occur up to six riders are law firms that serve other divisions and manufacturer cartels are expected to damage in a clear course for 2009 with a three-digit million sum.
Strategic information
As already sufficiently reports the IP addresses come from the general pool of data from the media protector GmbH in Augsburg [ Link ], which is by Telekom Austria called "Internet Detective", which tracks the eingentlich minimum successful Mitgliedschaftsberwerbung requires institutions such as the BDK. About the way the individual contractual or implied transfers of funds and information flows between the German legal representation [NZKG, Augsburg] in Austria, which now occur owners here could only speculate. A prosecutorial investigation is urgently required because it is not yet legally sound even if that was not publicly known and in Germany because of consecutive errors in silent discredit comer protector system of media GmbH in Augsburg ever approved for Austria. Particularly it appears questionable data protection legislation relevant action "over long periods of time an exact" exchange profile the infringer "to create [self-presentation Media Protector], as can be within the systematic Abmahntätigkeit the Registry LF-Law often take. Furthermore, it appears debatable whether the traffic between LF-Law and Telekom Austria from the point 2.5 of the voluntary commitment of the ISPA [ Link ] can be derived, since neither of the "private" is seen to fall even more the case of a domestic rights collecting society. The antitrust violation on the part of Telekom Austria more than obvious to assume on the part of Abmahnkartells. While it is within the commitment to individual providers to decide to proceed, however, by the evident lack of competence Telekom Austria to assess the sometimes extremely complex individual cases through the omission of an appropriate organization in information provisioning and testing of the persons concerned a clear advantage over the other ISPA members achieved. Of importance is also the ISPA-line in a press release published on the website of 27.08.2008 from the practice that was already practiced by Telekom Austria circumferentially distanced. An amazing process. "Excellent" in the system but the handling of requests in the technical level of Telekom Austria and in the LF-Law firm mentioned. We may assume that a "commercial" Excel spreadsheet procedures and establishing the IP addresses, Log data and hash values "emerge, enriched with fast connection holder data without any review by Telekom Austria and will be sent to the Registry LF-Law. Of any agreements with responsible departments of Telekom Austria are unknown, but assumed, given the mass of inquiries. The all illegal null examining the evidence [VLG. § 87 b ABS3 ". In particular the statement of sufficiently specific information on the suspicion of violation of the law include the facts establishing"] is considered to be on individual cases. In addition, a quote from many is called " Note: this standard may be illegal-EU (Non-compliant implementation). To provide information without a court order will usually be inadmissible. Access provider may be due to grant of § 13 ECG usually no information. At issue on appeal, these laws, please insert information provisioning not without assistance of legal counsel. "[Dr. Sabine gravel Szontagh, Tuwien]. To be particularly irritating must simplifying apply the reasoning: In the corresponding Abmahnsystemen in Germany, where the company Media Protector occurs GmbH beweisermittelndes company as a "sufficiently specific words" Always the control function of a "visual balance" - Keyword: - cited "test download" . Neither the warning letter [point 3] or in other information appears to Austria the "test download". This respect, the law firm LF-law insists on the concept of "recorded" infringement, which, given the sensitivity of the data [sexual preference] even in the case of actual infringer to high in the levels of the EU Regulation practice, an essential to be observed judge reserved in its wake. Additional point, and extremely relevant point here is for Austria, which is due to be considered in Austria to quoting extensively grant practices of IP addresses the only track an IP address is difficult as tangible evidence of illegal acts. Unlike in dynamic systems such as in telecom Germany are legally available data sufficient to conceal the perpetrator-IP. [ example link ] Although part of a technician of the Telekom Austria it expressed the opinion that Deutsche Telekom had saved the amount of data movement in emule network were documented. About relevance [without "Test Download"], and individual assessment is not known.
Strategic packages
After a successful "test run" in early August 2008 [package-name "07/06/2008"] followed the packages "24/08/2008" and "09/18/2008". [= Packages in Telekom Austria for information provisioning submitted Excel spreadsheets.] The first organized Analysis of log data by the media protector GmbH in Augsburg was held in March 2008. The time between log analysis [March to May 2008] used the LF-Law firm to create their own "profiles" for determining possible connection holders are multiple warnings may be served. It must be known ahead to be set OHG Rating 4Ob194/07v of 21.01.2008 [link ] are derived here for the right and clear the Registry LF-law, which this practice before a court was hardly have expected. In the profiles "multiple warnings" to identify policy options: Households are bombarded within days, or even on a day with three to five warnings. Households are confronted with a new step after the payment claim. After all, there is currently very little errors, like incorrect dates within the time limits. In addition, calls to the Registry, the prescreening of "call center"-like structures have arisen which were set up to channel at the expense might be expected. In such cases the person as a whole "likable" and "pre-school." Secured is also used to indicate the lack of processing of non-payer cases, either in civil or criminal matters significantly to a single geldabschöpfende methodology in the initial phase. Information on direct or lawyer negotiations hardly exist [see item "influence"]. undecided is whether the individual German rights holders to certify an economic and wettberwerbspolitisches interest is. A short test showed, however, a surprising information.
test lawsuit against IP 193.83.233.171, NN Salzburg Austria for violation of the pornography law. The review of the business of the GMV Media GmbH, D-Ochsenburg to Austria was on the side of the reference Amor Medien GmbH, A-Lochgau [alleged sales] any presence of the GMV Media GmbH to be determined. Striking, however, was the Cupid of the media GmbH without any age restriction censored exposed and extremely pornographic in any way, in part in close-up images published material. To investigate the Austrian authorities for jugendgefährdetem spreading to escape from pornogrpahischem material is called the Web page intentionally armor-medien.com, the data will be provided via a server in Salzburg.
Within the strategic packages can be found of course the most absurd constructs. Here is an example of the assertion of full debt totals for complete film works mentioned one, although the firm would be known as LF-Law to require that the files in question mini-excerpts of up to one sixth of the cinematographic size represented. Similarly, there are enough examples in the covenants of films have been deleted in the simplest way from other networks [eg RapidShare] on notice by the operator. Why are the rights of ownership and its German and Austrian legal representation in the case of emule networks has not gone down this path remains hidden from view, especially as the responsible company Media Protector GmbH particularly proud of the determination of "initial seeder", which is the "real" offenders refers. The same on the website of Media Protector expressed opinion that the document identified as illegal files are difficult to extinguish is counteracted by the positive results [eg rapishare].
Strategic influencing
Since the firm LF-Law not only developed the habit of Information Web sites and Internet forums has to spy on people seeking help, but this even after successful identification [eg. Data on the warning] is massively influenced by the author of the report does not quite present the identities in this report are given price. At least one known case in which the firm LF-Law a subscriber of an Internet forum on threats to put his contributions, which complied at all times the rules of freedom of deleting the operators of the website to let has been without these include the forum, one reason. In addition, other reports exist on a peculiar appearance of the LF-Law Firm [Link ]. Whether and how often this is practiced in telephone calls to households, it has not been warned, you can enter at risk because the fear of criminal charges in an absurd silence obligations. Another point of the sound practices contrary to law firms. Of being valued positively at all times as possible contacts in the auxiliary forums can not be reported.
information via the disclosure procedure
When the Telekom Austria to week 39 in response mails and phone statements to affected terminal owner any connection to the firm LF-law denied and made even the publication of data under a strict judge reservation now are the first letter appeared, the content can hardly illuminating than the obvious falsehoods of the previous weeks are referred to. On lawyers prepared sample letter to information pursuant to § 26.1 Privacy Act "about the processed data, the available information on their origin, the recipients or categories of recipients, the purpose of data use and the legal basis for this in general terms. The information also refers to any names and addresses of where they are entrusted with the processing of my data and took place when and by which collecting society or a private individual against a request for information about my person and which data were to grant information. ", the person concerned a reference to § 87 para 3 UrhG [!], together with statements such as" A mandated by the author "Internetdedektei" determined by a special software program participants with their IP address to Fileshareingsystemen at a time at which they other participants provide files for download. In the episode passes the author that IP address specified with the date and time - that is already individualized -. The responsible operator for information provisioning to the master data "These kinds of howlers reinforce the impression of the Telekom Austria legally completely helpless employees and you get the matter out of control is. Since this title is also applicable to the previously available "advice" of the Austrian consumer protection is Cz are the latest "instructions" to employees of Telekom Austria, the caller to the Austrian Consumer Protection to issue a very strange circumstance. [Text as consumer protection Web site: "Anyone who downloads the network copyrighted material, can be sued by the author."] The consumer protection still points to 99% on his lack of jurisdiction in copyright matters and issues but the nonsensical advice to the firm LF-Law in touch to connect and to pay the claim amount. This of course without further investigation. Meanwhile However, a data subject is animate while others Abgemahnt with the Austrian Data Protection Commission pursuant to § 30 DSG 2000 the ombudsman initiated. The first reactions of the DSK was competent and objective. In this whole area always is an extremely serious errors of management of Telekom Austria: Such a lot of requests and amounts of money can a competent and responsible department part of Telekom Austria will be submitted and processed only on knowledge and position, were being implemented seen with nieces data protection concerns. The unanimous false statements of the preceding staff suggest clear company directives, which prescribe these false statements. If, however, the negative case "Directive" to be tried as it would have a duty of the responsible department of Telekom Austria located your customers promptly provide expert advice on a simple letter and purpose of the call-center workers to be doing. Since this did not happen and flow at the same time more "allowances" which blithely denied by inkompentente employees of Telekom Austria, or disguised with meaningless information will have a financial interest in the longevity of the offending process information to insinuate. There may be an indirect recruiting procedures for before riders law firms, the "record" probably already active. It had held a simple statement that the consumers and customers their rights and obligations in the event of a received warning clears the needs of consumers and customers is sufficient enough. Then again probably resolve the issue of liability under immense and additional costs for individual cases and could hardly develop even a single case, no broad effect is definitely the regulatory hand of the endorsed government agencies required!
Information Procedure
It was at this point made abundantly clear that the author of the present disclosure procedure as against the decisions of the ruling OHG 4Ob141/07z , the subsequent Legal assistance request to the European Court, whose assessment of the Austrian reporting regulations are still pending and the looks to be considered comparatively. This really is not very controversial legal opinion of the author can be proven by the existence of "fake files" in the systematic Abmahnsystem. Previously: The mere disclosure of the personal data is up to a supreme court ruling in Austria trozt an existing "commitment" of the Austrian Provider shall strictly conditional. In this respect, comes the following assessment of the situation by the Austrian consortium data [ link] an immense weight: " Disclosure of user information to third parties without a court order by the provider is therefore not permitted. Very often behind these requests advocacy groups or lawyers to pursue the alleged or actual violations. A ruling by the provider allows those affected to contact us directly. These are then often faced with relatively large claims, and - regardless of the actual legal situation -. pressured to pay these claims within a short period in order to avoid legal action for the interests involved by giving in a lot of pressure such claims, regardless of whether they right or not. From Overview of the Working DATA is to reject this approach in principle, because a kind of "parallel justice 'is created. There is this also the risk that false claims are asserted by means of such warnings. In the presence of reasonable requirements and such evidence can be filed in court and the data is subsequently requested by the court. Recent court decisions confirm position. Also, recent court decisions acknowledge the consortium DATA position as they fulfill the information requirements, then the customer data of both dynamic and static IP addresses of any kind. "considered suitable in this light, the threat of LF-Law firm to see to view the Abgemahnt for failure to pay the absurd claims promptly and without further response because of the alleged proliferation of pornography. It is present even without even a single proof threatened with heavy prison sentences and the statement in the space provided the authorities would be "officially" determine, as the connection owner pornographic works one has "more people under 16 years made available". The usual model undressing in Germany the individual aspects and especially the criminal part of at least half-way matching, already issued rulings in this area was the LF-Law Firm in Austria too much work. About the apparent fraud model fits the point no. 5 within the warning, said the opposite to the above-mentioned legal opinion of the OHG 4Ob194/07v the case: "... you have committed to use your Internet access in any way or to have to take other claim that leads to impairment of third parties . This is a contract with the explicit protection for third parties, so the benefit of our clients, helping you not only for your behavior, but also for the conduct of those persons who use their Internet access makes liable. " Because of "media lawyers" may be required the first and only ruling on the OHG "Nuisance liability" is likely to know here are derived justifiably intent. Ways in which the warning as such corresponds to Austrian law can not be resolved. If you compare the other hand, in the factual area [eg Tathergangsbeschreibungen] with German standard mass warnings, it falls under any minimum quality.
about the importance of "fake files"
defintion shortened: Besides the title, the size of the file of the so-called hash value a stable system employed in the evaluation of each file just under "copyright infringement" is . The company Media Protector GmbH, Augsburg determined by order of a Rights holder to the special value of a hash file located in emule2000 network and logs the movement of IP addresses through this hash value. Already known in 5 cases, hash values were recorded, the [mentioned in the appropriate warnings] in the media company known way with a new protector of rights holders and, above all, on the division pornography secreted were distorted by a change in title.
example: "Darwin's Nightmare" - ARTE documentation (RI Hubert Sauper well) [title] with hash for Vivian Schmitt - XXX fever - Videorama GmbH
Although the LF-Law firm to a change in the cost-saving " regular " Warning letter omitted [FSK FSK 12 to 18] does not change the basic fact that there is a copyright violation. How this will ultimately be handled in court is to be seen.
Of greatest importance is the existence of "fake files" for the procedure within the Telekom Austria, said it must be assumed that out in the "sufficiently specific information on the suspicion of violation of the facts establishing" exactly does it work here, no " normally present. No matter whether you're "Recital Guidelines" from EU regulations, OHG judgments [eg. from nuisance liability deriving], or even logical Arguments to rate moves: The retrieval not be done without court order, as would have to decide is the right of the copyright holder's failure to end users in good faith, acting only on an individual basis by a judge. At least one case of warned "classic" fake file that was detected by the system itself is to write down. This usually means that garbage of a title of the copyright holder has been assigned and was also changed to a "harmless" title appeared in the warnings. This shows both the limits of media used by the Frima protector procedure: Let the hash-proof, which in Germany classified by the courts in part will be insufficient for an initial suspicion itself be sufficient without the "test download". For a civil disclosure procedure without a court reservation along with a zero-examination by the Provider, it is completely useless because it creates a huge error, which are also dozens of concerned occurred convincing as the innocent or proven 0-uploader were reprimanded for illegal upload-actions. [Example 0-upload-mode: link].
Introduction
since August of 2008, the I designed webblog [ link ] and another German information page [ link ] a growing number of Austrian citizens who are on these pages about the topic " warnings from German porn producer in Austria by the firm Längle + Fussenegger, Bregenz ", provide in the short follow-LF-called Law. Justified the claims in the letters made claims with alleged violations of exploitation films from the producers in the so-called P2P file sharing, particularly in the so-called emule2000 network. The known details are now presented in abbreviated form. The result after two months is sobering: As there of the parties concerned failed a united front against the most absurd and illegal hardly produce about bidding processes and to the attorney area into serious qualitative deficiencies are noted, this report will necessarily depend on the competent authorities sent, which are hereby invited for an immediate halt to the activities of all participants to clarify to ensure the situation before OHG. The clarification of the legal situation is dealt with by a State, as the as the only "data merchants" in Austria Telekom Austria is occurring Provider absolutely overwhelmed with this task. Since it is already collected and Researched amounts of data involved would have no effect of this approach in the field of other possible civil prosecution. For immediate comments would be appreciated. In part, be suspicious given the lead in police investigations can and a "test complaint" is set. A general statement of the competent Bar Association is urgently required. Please send the documents entsprehenden at the end of the address. Please note: all the answers, no answers will be published. Standing
this, the reference, which is not the pursuit of copyright infringement on the Internet by Austrian prosecutors the subject of this report, but the manner of the approach is criticized. The tendency of the authors of the report, the development in Germany considers exemplary. The division of the offenses with minor cases in the claim limits and by judges decision established, commercially oriented types of injuries would be useful to medium term for Austria. In this respect, this is also the chance of the result of the enormous to develop chaotic development of the affair following a solid solution for the future. The report, in which about put 170 hours of work goes, the Austrian taxpayers free of charge and is solely the personal opinions of the blog owner dar.
Systematic Abmahntätigkeit
As the firm's clients LF-Law are satisfied that: INO GmbH, Wuppertal + Hustler Europe GmbH, Krefeld + GMV GmbH & Co. KG, Ochsenburg + SG Video GmbH, Germany [Z-factor media Illertissen] + BBVideo GmbH, Duisburg + Cazzo GmbH, Berlin + Tino Media, Berlin + Cyber Net GmbH, Offenbach.
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit by AZ packages
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit to monthly data, and be warned households
Graphics: Systematic Abmahntätigkeit after warnings Shual blog with comparative value Pásah blog [name changed for security reasons] and maximum value
explanation of the graphs: From database records, current AZ-number, track data and comparative data from Germany, a conservative holding the average can be achieved. The real figure is double the area. Basically, many households receive multiple warnings, so that should the above data [Chart 2] are multiplied by a factor of 2. One determined by a Qualifying statement of a competent technician to Datenaufbearbeitung Telekom Austria confirms over "several hundred" requests to 09/20/2008 the previous image. [Note: All personal statements in this report can by the author in this report in writing and verified by specific names and addresses. See item: "influence". To clarify the data and other information in the report satisfies the requirement of a public body to give the system of inquiry. Personal information may be processed only on request.] According to the current situation can be up to date at the end of week 40 with a total 1540 warnings be expected, which can be estimate to a claim amount of approximately € 1.2 million. The "potential" for 2008 is estimated at approximately € 3.7 million, these sums are still able to increase greatly. [See Ad volume alone in the district of the General Prosecutor Hamm, Germany, first semester, for the same individual claim amount: € 27.6 million] According to [warning, if necessary: see Appendix], the LF-Law shall be informed by the end KW40 well over € 0.2 million to Telekom Austria removed as Ausfwandsentschädigung. The "potential" for 2008 is € 0.5 million. The economic losses [consumer protection, telecoms, legal fees, Consumption losses, debt, etc.] is consistently on the same level as the claim amount. There may be only one law firm is currently active and organized predictable occur up to six riders are law firms that serve other divisions and manufacturer cartels are expected to damage in a clear course for 2009 with a three-digit million sum.
Strategic information
As already sufficiently reports the IP addresses come from the general pool of data from the media protector GmbH in Augsburg [ Link ], which is by Telekom Austria called "Internet Detective", which tracks the eingentlich minimum successful Mitgliedschaftsberwerbung requires institutions such as the BDK. About the way the individual contractual or implied transfers of funds and information flows between the German legal representation [NZKG, Augsburg] in Austria, which now occur owners here could only speculate. A prosecutorial investigation is urgently required because it is not yet legally sound even if that was not publicly known and in Germany because of consecutive errors in silent discredit comer protector system of media GmbH in Augsburg ever approved for Austria. Particularly it appears questionable data protection legislation relevant action "over long periods of time an exact" exchange profile the infringer "to create [self-presentation Media Protector], as can be within the systematic Abmahntätigkeit the Registry LF-Law often take. Furthermore, it appears debatable whether the traffic between LF-Law and Telekom Austria from the point 2.5 of the voluntary commitment of the ISPA [ Link ] can be derived, since neither of the "private" is seen to fall even more the case of a domestic rights collecting society. The antitrust violation on the part of Telekom Austria more than obvious to assume on the part of Abmahnkartells. While it is within the commitment to individual providers to decide to proceed, however, by the evident lack of competence Telekom Austria to assess the sometimes extremely complex individual cases through the omission of an appropriate organization in information provisioning and testing of the persons concerned a clear advantage over the other ISPA members achieved. Of importance is also the ISPA-line in a press release published on the website of 27.08.2008 from the practice that was already practiced by Telekom Austria circumferentially distanced. An amazing process. "Excellent" in the system but the handling of requests in the technical level of Telekom Austria and in the LF-Law firm mentioned. We may assume that a "commercial" Excel spreadsheet procedures and establishing the IP addresses, Log data and hash values "emerge, enriched with fast connection holder data without any review by Telekom Austria and will be sent to the Registry LF-Law. Of any agreements with responsible departments of Telekom Austria are unknown, but assumed, given the mass of inquiries. The all illegal null examining the evidence [VLG. § 87 b ABS3 ". In particular the statement of sufficiently specific information on the suspicion of violation of the law include the facts establishing"] is considered to be on individual cases. In addition, a quote from many is called " Note: this standard may be illegal-EU (Non-compliant implementation). To provide information without a court order will usually be inadmissible. Access provider may be due to grant of § 13 ECG usually no information. At issue on appeal, these laws, please insert information provisioning not without assistance of legal counsel. "[Dr. Sabine gravel Szontagh, Tuwien]. To be particularly irritating must simplifying apply the reasoning: In the corresponding Abmahnsystemen in Germany, where the company Media Protector occurs GmbH beweisermittelndes company as a "sufficiently specific words" Always the control function of a "visual balance" - Keyword: - cited "test download" . Neither the warning letter [point 3] or in other information appears to Austria the "test download". This respect, the law firm LF-law insists on the concept of "recorded" infringement, which, given the sensitivity of the data [sexual preference] even in the case of actual infringer to high in the levels of the EU Regulation practice, an essential to be observed judge reserved in its wake. Additional point, and extremely relevant point here is for Austria, which is due to be considered in Austria to quoting extensively grant practices of IP addresses the only track an IP address is difficult as tangible evidence of illegal acts. Unlike in dynamic systems such as in telecom Germany are legally available data sufficient to conceal the perpetrator-IP. [ example link ] Although part of a technician of the Telekom Austria it expressed the opinion that Deutsche Telekom had saved the amount of data movement in emule network were documented. About relevance [without "Test Download"], and individual assessment is not known.
Strategic packages
After a successful "test run" in early August 2008 [package-name "07/06/2008"] followed the packages "24/08/2008" and "09/18/2008". [= Packages in Telekom Austria for information provisioning submitted Excel spreadsheets.] The first organized Analysis of log data by the media protector GmbH in Augsburg was held in March 2008. The time between log analysis [March to May 2008] used the LF-Law firm to create their own "profiles" for determining possible connection holders are multiple warnings may be served. It must be known ahead to be set OHG Rating 4Ob194/07v of 21.01.2008 [link ] are derived here for the right and clear the Registry LF-law, which this practice before a court was hardly have expected. In the profiles "multiple warnings" to identify policy options: Households are bombarded within days, or even on a day with three to five warnings. Households are confronted with a new step after the payment claim. After all, there is currently very little errors, like incorrect dates within the time limits. In addition, calls to the Registry, the prescreening of "call center"-like structures have arisen which were set up to channel at the expense might be expected. In such cases the person as a whole "likable" and "pre-school." Secured is also used to indicate the lack of processing of non-payer cases, either in civil or criminal matters significantly to a single geldabschöpfende methodology in the initial phase. Information on direct or lawyer negotiations hardly exist [see item "influence"]. undecided is whether the individual German rights holders to certify an economic and wettberwerbspolitisches interest is. A short test showed, however, a surprising information.
test lawsuit against IP 193.83.233.171, NN Salzburg Austria for violation of the pornography law. The review of the business of the GMV Media GmbH, D-Ochsenburg to Austria was on the side of the reference Amor Medien GmbH, A-Lochgau [alleged sales] any presence of the GMV Media GmbH to be determined. Striking, however, was the Cupid of the media GmbH without any age restriction censored exposed and extremely pornographic in any way, in part in close-up images published material. To investigate the Austrian authorities for jugendgefährdetem spreading to escape from pornogrpahischem material is called the Web page intentionally armor-medien.com, the data will be provided via a server in Salzburg.
Within the strategic packages can be found of course the most absurd constructs. Here is an example of the assertion of full debt totals for complete film works mentioned one, although the firm would be known as LF-Law to require that the files in question mini-excerpts of up to one sixth of the cinematographic size represented. Similarly, there are enough examples in the covenants of films have been deleted in the simplest way from other networks [eg RapidShare] on notice by the operator. Why are the rights of ownership and its German and Austrian legal representation in the case of emule networks has not gone down this path remains hidden from view, especially as the responsible company Media Protector GmbH particularly proud of the determination of "initial seeder", which is the "real" offenders refers. The same on the website of Media Protector expressed opinion that the document identified as illegal files are difficult to extinguish is counteracted by the positive results [eg rapishare].
Strategic influencing
Since the firm LF-Law not only developed the habit of Information Web sites and Internet forums has to spy on people seeking help, but this even after successful identification [eg. Data on the warning] is massively influenced by the author of the report does not quite present the identities in this report are given price. At least one known case in which the firm LF-Law a subscriber of an Internet forum on threats to put his contributions, which complied at all times the rules of freedom of deleting the operators of the website to let has been without these include the forum, one reason. In addition, other reports exist on a peculiar appearance of the LF-Law Firm [Link ]. Whether and how often this is practiced in telephone calls to households, it has not been warned, you can enter at risk because the fear of criminal charges in an absurd silence obligations. Another point of the sound practices contrary to law firms. Of being valued positively at all times as possible contacts in the auxiliary forums can not be reported.
information via the disclosure procedure
When the Telekom Austria to week 39 in response mails and phone statements to affected terminal owner any connection to the firm LF-law denied and made even the publication of data under a strict judge reservation now are the first letter appeared, the content can hardly illuminating than the obvious falsehoods of the previous weeks are referred to. On lawyers prepared sample letter to information pursuant to § 26.1 Privacy Act "about the processed data, the available information on their origin, the recipients or categories of recipients, the purpose of data use and the legal basis for this in general terms. The information also refers to any names and addresses of where they are entrusted with the processing of my data and took place when and by which collecting society or a private individual against a request for information about my person and which data were to grant information. ", the person concerned a reference to § 87 para 3 UrhG [!], together with statements such as" A mandated by the author "Internetdedektei" determined by a special software program participants with their IP address to Fileshareingsystemen at a time at which they other participants provide files for download. In the episode passes the author that IP address specified with the date and time - that is already individualized -. The responsible operator for information provisioning to the master data "These kinds of howlers reinforce the impression of the Telekom Austria legally completely helpless employees and you get the matter out of control is. Since this title is also applicable to the previously available "advice" of the Austrian consumer protection is Cz are the latest "instructions" to employees of Telekom Austria, the caller to the Austrian Consumer Protection to issue a very strange circumstance. [Text as consumer protection Web site: "Anyone who downloads the network copyrighted material, can be sued by the author."] The consumer protection still points to 99% on his lack of jurisdiction in copyright matters and issues but the nonsensical advice to the firm LF-Law in touch to connect and to pay the claim amount. This of course without further investigation. Meanwhile However, a data subject is animate while others Abgemahnt with the Austrian Data Protection Commission pursuant to § 30 DSG 2000 the ombudsman initiated. The first reactions of the DSK was competent and objective. In this whole area always is an extremely serious errors of management of Telekom Austria: Such a lot of requests and amounts of money can a competent and responsible department part of Telekom Austria will be submitted and processed only on knowledge and position, were being implemented seen with nieces data protection concerns. The unanimous false statements of the preceding staff suggest clear company directives, which prescribe these false statements. If, however, the negative case "Directive" to be tried as it would have a duty of the responsible department of Telekom Austria located your customers promptly provide expert advice on a simple letter and purpose of the call-center workers to be doing. Since this did not happen and flow at the same time more "allowances" which blithely denied by inkompentente employees of Telekom Austria, or disguised with meaningless information will have a financial interest in the longevity of the offending process information to insinuate. There may be an indirect recruiting procedures for before riders law firms, the "record" probably already active. It had held a simple statement that the consumers and customers their rights and obligations in the event of a received warning clears the needs of consumers and customers is sufficient enough. Then again probably resolve the issue of liability under immense and additional costs for individual cases and could hardly develop even a single case, no broad effect is definitely the regulatory hand of the endorsed government agencies required!
Information Procedure
It was at this point made abundantly clear that the author of the present disclosure procedure as against the decisions of the ruling OHG 4Ob141/07z , the subsequent Legal assistance request to the European Court, whose assessment of the Austrian reporting regulations are still pending and the looks to be considered comparatively. This really is not very controversial legal opinion of the author can be proven by the existence of "fake files" in the systematic Abmahnsystem. Previously: The mere disclosure of the personal data is up to a supreme court ruling in Austria trozt an existing "commitment" of the Austrian Provider shall strictly conditional. In this respect, comes the following assessment of the situation by the Austrian consortium data [ link] an immense weight: " Disclosure of user information to third parties without a court order by the provider is therefore not permitted. Very often behind these requests advocacy groups or lawyers to pursue the alleged or actual violations. A ruling by the provider allows those affected to contact us directly. These are then often faced with relatively large claims, and - regardless of the actual legal situation -. pressured to pay these claims within a short period in order to avoid legal action for the interests involved by giving in a lot of pressure such claims, regardless of whether they right or not. From Overview of the Working DATA is to reject this approach in principle, because a kind of "parallel justice 'is created. There is this also the risk that false claims are asserted by means of such warnings. In the presence of reasonable requirements and such evidence can be filed in court and the data is subsequently requested by the court. Recent court decisions confirm position. Also, recent court decisions acknowledge the consortium DATA position as they fulfill the information requirements, then the customer data of both dynamic and static IP addresses of any kind. "considered suitable in this light, the threat of LF-Law firm to see to view the Abgemahnt for failure to pay the absurd claims promptly and without further response because of the alleged proliferation of pornography. It is present even without even a single proof threatened with heavy prison sentences and the statement in the space provided the authorities would be "officially" determine, as the connection owner pornographic works one has "more people under 16 years made available". The usual model undressing in Germany the individual aspects and especially the criminal part of at least half-way matching, already issued rulings in this area was the LF-Law Firm in Austria too much work. About the apparent fraud model fits the point no. 5 within the warning, said the opposite to the above-mentioned legal opinion of the OHG 4Ob194/07v the case: "... you have committed to use your Internet access in any way or to have to take other claim that leads to impairment of third parties . This is a contract with the explicit protection for third parties, so the benefit of our clients, helping you not only for your behavior, but also for the conduct of those persons who use their Internet access makes liable. " Because of "media lawyers" may be required the first and only ruling on the OHG "Nuisance liability" is likely to know here are derived justifiably intent. Ways in which the warning as such corresponds to Austrian law can not be resolved. If you compare the other hand, in the factual area [eg Tathergangsbeschreibungen] with German standard mass warnings, it falls under any minimum quality.
about the importance of "fake files"
defintion shortened: Besides the title, the size of the file of the so-called hash value a stable system employed in the evaluation of each file just under "copyright infringement" is . The company Media Protector GmbH, Augsburg determined by order of a Rights holder to the special value of a hash file located in emule2000 network and logs the movement of IP addresses through this hash value. Already known in 5 cases, hash values were recorded, the [mentioned in the appropriate warnings] in the media company known way with a new protector of rights holders and, above all, on the division pornography secreted were distorted by a change in title.
example: "Darwin's Nightmare" - ARTE documentation (RI Hubert Sauper well) [title] with hash for Vivian Schmitt - XXX fever - Videorama GmbH
Although the LF-Law firm to a change in the cost-saving " regular " Warning letter omitted [FSK FSK 12 to 18] does not change the basic fact that there is a copyright violation. How this will ultimately be handled in court is to be seen.
Of greatest importance is the existence of "fake files" for the procedure within the Telekom Austria, said it must be assumed that out in the "sufficiently specific information on the suspicion of violation of the facts establishing" exactly does it work here, no " normally present. No matter whether you're "Recital Guidelines" from EU regulations, OHG judgments [eg. from nuisance liability deriving], or even logical Arguments to rate moves: The retrieval not be done without court order, as would have to decide is the right of the copyright holder's failure to end users in good faith, acting only on an individual basis by a judge. At least one case of warned "classic" fake file that was detected by the system itself is to write down. This usually means that garbage of a title of the copyright holder has been assigned and was also changed to a "harmless" title appeared in the warnings. This shows both the limits of media used by the Frima protector procedure: Let the hash-proof, which in Germany classified by the courts in part will be insufficient for an initial suspicion itself be sufficient without the "test download". For a civil disclosure procedure without a court reservation along with a zero-examination by the Provider, it is completely useless because it creates a huge error, which are also dozens of concerned occurred convincing as the innocent or proven 0-uploader were reprimanded for illegal upload-actions. [Example 0-upload-mode: link].
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)