Day 30 - STA Frankfurt
Pre-realease
to the prosecutor at the District Court Frankfurt am Main
Konrad-Adenauer-Strasse 20
60 256 Frankfurt
access to the file of the right ansa Walt firm Korn Meier & Partners, client DigiProtect GmbH
with the press in the magazine FOCUS [ online version ], which I personally have no connection , has been in the scandal over the contracts of DigiProtect society for the protection of digital media mbH, Krögerstraße 2, 60313 Frankfurt in terms of those contracts with the licensee company John Stagliano Inc., SC, company, Evil Angels, Inc., and the person of John Stagliano, a new dynamics arise. Since it is necessary now to the end of next week the results of my extensive submit personal research concerned investigators and courts, I ask you kindly to give an opinion, or a short message about the time that is required for this.
Personal area
Desirable opinion
Even in the systems of public prosecutors' handling of investigations on criminal charges of "suspicion of violation of collective rights under § 106 UrhGff by participants within a p2p file-sharing" where a principal organizational clarify with the complainant the competent public prosecutor before going, and where test steps can be minimized [Richter reservation "by Private prosecution "] is, according to the sample prosecutor food while a" "provided personal data, but is also found here the words" direct transfer in accordance with the inspection of files. "[ document ] Now is this the end of solid medium-sized enterprises that a credible impression in the area of the law firm to appearances left to make sense in this direction is also the expression of the responsible Minister of Justice of North Rhine-Westphalia to understand about the procedure in NRW. " The security of data against misuse by private inquirer might even by a judge of title, in which the rights of ownership and the legitimate interest in the information-here access to the file-tested, are better protected than in the current procedures [ press release ] This contrasts with the ambiguous situation of the practice Akteineinsichtsverfahren with the dubious rights collecting society DigiProtect GmbH in the STA Frankfurt. A clarifying word STA Frankfurt would be the area currently in the opinion of the author attached.
justification
Of course, the adoption of the on 18/08/2008 "leaked" contract in various ways nature is illegal for accuracy have. Here are three Key points out crystallized: first
Always was the question in the space in how far the in the warnings of the law firm Korn Meier & mentioned partner " exclusive right to film the company John Stagliano Inc. evaluated via distributed computer networks and to publish " with the existing and above to be settled protection laws [eg § 7 (1) + (3) JöSchG and many more] to be agreed. The contract now emerged Text to Implement suitable measures to Prevent The economic Disadvantages Lices is suffering "is next to a simple denial of the allegations in the press this point of the contract and not enough to replace the missing permission of a public and legitimate institution. Also corresponds to this point is not the logical thinking, because the grain in the reprimand of the lawyers Meier & Partners applicable test downloads [singular] that in the extensive rights and economic damage focusses contract is completely unnecessary. In addition, the common practice of German prosecutor is to write down that accept this never more detail [warning] defined "test download" as the initial suspicion for the determination of personal data [ Document Logistep "lists ], a practice no earlier than mid-2009 with the announced Revision of the OLG Frankfurt-judgment [presumably Logistep AG] 52/07 11U AZ will be clarified. For now, this point is important, as was As part of a public prosecutor's request for information under § 113 TKG informed ... "in the warning letter of the law firm Korn Meier & Parts [an a) meaningless and absurd organization with a description the b) [TGK " Access to data that are subject to the secrecy of telecommunications is allowed only if the requirements of the relevant statutory provisions for this ."] under the contracts DigiProtect GmbH + Stagliano Inc. can hardly be seen as acceptable and c) and "qualitative" behind the more solid letters from law firms to issue written warnings background in the particular industry is lagging behind her. [Example U + C, Regensburg: After explaining the TGK § 113-process ". By inspection of the public prosecutor investigation file, we then come to your investigation file "], so that in the out of court settlement procedures of the above-mentioned core minimizing staatsanwaltschftlicher activities, "Judge reserved by private prosecution" to be undermined by unfair representations. - [See brief technical note test download]
second Another indication is that against the person and the company of John Stagliano a achtpünktiges Court proceedings for illegal distribution of "obscene pornography" in the United States of America is pending. Among them, the indictment point 7, in which John Stagliano is accused on 21/01/2008 minors "obscene pornography" to have offered over the Internet. A contract was signed on 24/01/2008 indicated without any mention of a youth protection of title is not a particularly strong sense of wrongdoing out in this area. A pre-mail has been sent to the investigating prosecutor. A more comprehensive approach in the post is here, in which an opinion of the STA Frankfurt would be more than useful.
third With the signature date of the contract is bestandslos because the Licensor assures that the film does not work "provisions under criminal law" violate. well it is the "content", meaning "world" extremely likely to be controversial. But especially in the area "in section 174 of Particular et.seq. Criminal Code" would be a verification "from § 184" was necessary because the subsequent warning lawyers grain Meier & Partners explicitly to "§ 184.1 11 para 3 SCC will focus ". Since the signing of the Treaty and American protection laws, which include laws germans in comparison to far more rigorous punishment catalogs a) be violated in the potential, b)-see notes have to be violated in any case, c) not mentioned, but can also apply for the Vorgegen DigiProtect GmbH also does not affect the contract be evaluated.
4th Since the DigiProtect GmbH by a court of High Court of London confirmed in future also on the very "lucrative" UK market will be active is to clarify the matter to accept there that are also only fianzielle interests in the forefront of what "suitable measures "contrary. Here a separate opinion of the court and the press will be required.
summarized conclusion: It would be highly desirable in the next documents that are relevant to the Institutions and the press are sent to be able to attach a statement from the STA Frankfurt.
Sincerely
Note "Test Download": It should be mentioned here that the real control of movements on torrent files that you can see from the above case as well, since "0Seeder - 1Leecher" [Source: bitreactor. to] always in the stable mode is seeder, which inevitably means as with the "reliable evidence identified and documented" movements of other an upload option for others. In this respect, the denial of DigiProtect GmbH is completely implausible. Also, write down that the strategy of surveillance and the removal of torrent files prevented from the networks and every time the press allegations by evaluating the 1-Leecher-Torrents, can verify the contract in the DigiProtect GmbH and John Stagliano Inc. located films. Private People here, however, punishable in this process. Yet here is a prosecuting authority is well ergebnisslos since, for example in the so-called "torrent networks," to which the log of the company in the background DigiProtect GmbH concentrates, combined with an IP address only the application on a server for a file is. This process can also always a) contain false or fake IP address, or b) [see test series Tadayoshi Kohno, University of Washington - Laser Printer] also technical problems mean in regard to the assignment to the Metainformationsdateien can. Even the negative response to a data request from the company log is in effect an offer of log firm based.
0 comments:
Post a Comment