Day 25 - Stag Party part I
After Frima DigiProtect GmbH, Frankfurt, together with attorney so far not identified in court, nor in the public, commented on the leaked treaty with well-known porn mogul John Stagliano is the time to analyze the strategic situation.
I The situation in the U.S.
The leaked contract for the previously very weak position of the Ministry of Justice of the United States of America in the "Obscenity Case "Achieve against Stagliano considerably enhanced. Previously, the defendant because of the rather marginal accusations, despite high levels of penalties [32 years imprisonment + x00000US $ sentence] clear upper hand in the media. In addition, Stagliano was yesterday reap a rich check in other proceedings . Another setback for the investigators of the Obscenity Task Force is to write down, since the end of June had to connect the judges appointed Kozinski on the case back because you Stagliano products in his place.
The leak of the contract is salt in the wound of the investigators. For incomprehensible, it has been in the case against Stagliano Although a police consultation carried out, but no documents were sighted, and certainly not the leaked contract that would have carried the proximity [+ 01/24/2008 21:01:08] on specific allegations of the indictment a relevant indicator of the investigators may be. [ Udo Vetter view devinitiv worthless compared to this strong evidence, " addition to the slogan" Turn Piracy Into Profit "is interesting to note that the agreement the company expressly grants the exclusive rights to set the film in sharing this is not, however. necessarily to say that this happens also to attract other users. Rather, we understand the clause as a clarification that the owner just no other rights relating to the use awarded in file sharing. "]
The state today. The leaked contract was for the investigators in the U.S. leaked, and asked for comments This is, understandably, still there is sufficient completely for the rest of Germany, if the leaked agreement is within the official range of the method. built against Stagliano will be it to do only in theory carry a letter of intent to an investigation.
II, the situation in Germany
Of the American operations disconnected is not to be questioned in Germany, as such a contract to criminal charges against p2p file-sharing users Germany [and presumably also Coming British file sharers could lead], whose methods were certainly put in the ground under § 153 with reference to the private prosecution. For it is of general knowledge of the contract was not reviewed by the prosecutor. Now, however, due to the possible chain of evidence, especially under the consideration of a possible defense strategy for Stagliano forced to buy a high amount of cash from the process, U.S. can give a sitaution in which a public prosecution on identical test site is necessary. Must also be recommended that the entire area DigiProtect GmbH "on hold will be provided. Here is a note of that arise due to the generous time limits of the Copyright Act regarding the rights collecting society any disadvantage identified activities in the works to be tested under the contracts fall DigiProtect GmbH. The argument for a preventive effect that is require mandatory mass warnings given professional opinions to the contrary evidence irrelevant. Nevertheless, yes DigiProtect is always the possibility in the comment areas of the respective exchange trading portal under each title they represent no particular effort [mass warning = much more effort = 1:500] adequate warnings to place, and / or those responsible for the sharing according to the clarification the contract status to undertake in this regard. And ultimately, the appeal DigiProtect GmbH on the highly successful legal representation legal means.
Since the Justice Department in Frankfurt, Hesse, and the STA has not yet to the example in NRW discussed "new recommendations" for investigations of STAs have expressed in this area is the position unclear. From Hesse recently, only the highly critical verdict of the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court to be transmitted. In this respect, but now the Ministry of Justice can, diametrically opposed to the chaotic situation in NRW to announce because of the incidents to the Digi Protect GmbH, a consistent approach, which in turn with the professionals within the justice system to must be developed. If the already so only need the publication.
The state today: a letter to the authorities at the weekend line is completed and submitted.
II The situation in Great Britain
Here is only clear that some have made the strategic decision of DigiProtect GmbH also want this cake to published with the Court is substantiated. How far the court on the contract with Stagliano was informed, or whether he was ever presented is unclear. A letter to the Court, after examining the appeal and submitted letters to the English message is one of the steps at the weekend to be prepared and implemented
0 comments:
Post a Comment