Day 24 - Interim Report + Post article
Durch verschiedene durchaus themenbezogene Ereignisse, die mit will be included in future work there was to do a lot of background work. As of today, now, an extensive series will be posted and mailed, whichever had to say just in time runs.
Pre-realease: Justice Political situation NRW - File sharing
must Once again the justice policy of the State of North Rhine-Westphalia to the charge a chance in the design of a sustainable strategy can be used in reference to have on the treatment of crime missed the internet. The cardinal error dating back to June 2oo8: Instead of acting on the basis of very clear decision of the Ministers of Justice Conference in Celle to develop a viable concept dashed politically unwise, the Minister of Justice NRW, Roswitha Müller-Piepenkötter with a typical " Friday the 13th " product before. Former own reservations about the decision at Celle request to the Federal Government for a civil right to information of the right holders [RI] of Internet crime in the copyright area had been replaced. Oddly enough, the already installed and simply extrapolated to the judge, subject to 01 September 2008 comprehensive revision of § 97 UrhG ignoring [Quote: "The security of the data against the misuse of private inquirer might even by a judge of title, in which the rights ownership and the legitimate interest be tested at the inquiry, be better protected than in the current procedures "] allows you to be responsible for a very interesting confession, which ultimately coincides with my observations, which provide, however, the question is why in all these years not managed to administrative rules for consideration of legitimate interest to present and it has done nothing against even the most obvious abuses much more problematic for the progress of the matter is this quote. "Who the other hand, private individuals will deny access to such data really should, consequently, the claim of right holders to prohibit access to the investigation files. But that would mean to abolish copyright protection in this area completely. I can not imagine is that this is wanted by constitutionally minded people . "The chosen by the Minister means the public an ongoing discussion in the General Prosecutor districts under their leadership on this propaganda, and not very enlightening level to offer up is certainly no Art in the events surrounding the STA Wuppertal [investigation of agency head], the use of tax money for "support services" to the RI, prosecutor capitulation in the organizational field, etc., a clear introduce political position. Even less information was non-suited the tabloid press NRW to take the freshening wind from their sails. Hardly surprising: Since the press release, the Justice Minister is silent on the subject.
After many rumors and corresponding media field damage now at the beginning of August 2008 by appointed mouths trying to explain to the citizens in NRW which means a not quite complete abolition of copyright protection, designed by rule of law, thinking people: "The Public Ministry [NRW] pursuing since mid-July, only pirates or users of file sharing, the illegal at least 3000 or 200 audio files from video files the network have loaded. "[ Ulrich Hermanski , spokesman Justizminterium NRW] Afterwards strove practices, reduce primarily the spokesman of the STA Cologne, the exquisite Attorney Axel Steel, the absurdity of what is said:" We focus our attention that is also what is offered. Is it, for example, a full movie and maybe even to one who has started not even in Germany? Should this be the case, may be an infringement on commercial scale and well below the thresholds determine I have just described. "Almost a record five days later showed the STA-pneumatic tube in Cologne really is not quite Abmahnungsverstopft: "Absolutely no fun to understand the prosecutors finally, when it comes to the distribution of films with pornographic content. Such strips often offered illegally on the network have no age verification. In such cases, the Attorney General Steel, joins for copyright infringement or a violation of youth protection . And then the prosecutors in the Rhine region already come into action when there are 100 movie files or clips is. "Perhaps lacking the protection of minors in the bedroom simply because readers have to be held there for more clever. The sake of completeness, the
- 100 movie files between 70Gigabyte and 1.43 gigabytes of -100 to 1 movie show already make a very large margin, however, 100 clips [300MB] translated into German lawyers "is even the attempt punishable" under § [avi.] [rare.] ... can ... to ....
- the thoroughly modern opinion of Attorney Axel Steel on "youth-typical behavior" combined with the presented "3000-audio-file-limit + pre-realese criterion" plus fictitious line with countries such as Baden-Wurttemberg, the legal opinion of the local justice minister of the country Baden-Würtemmberg, Ulrich Goll rather not meet: "The fun stops when not only a few copies of the Friends, but within a very short time, hundreds of songs and movies by unknown persons to be exchanged via Internet exchanges "[" often are the authorities of children have been on the track, use the family PC to do so, the spokesman for the Cologne Public Prosecutor General, Franz-Heinrich Pohl, the rethink ".] At some point we are certainly agree.
That's not all that special about the current development. Not even about the statements of" adopted [federal] guidelines "to" recommendations to the General Prosecutor to investigators "[= continuation of determine at will without sufficient management policies], and only through this Maneuver the political initiative of the federal justice minister has come to nothing. [It's the mass of thought should not take too much account. . The law does not care if 10Tsde or 5 cases in "legally controversial" areas are completed] The uniqueness lies in this quote from Attorney Axel Steel: "However, it is so - and even then we move into an increasingly crystallising uniform federal regulation. " too, , which brings us back to the entrance:" The Ministers of Justice and Attorney General to appeal to the federal legislature, the civil law of copyright protection be designed so that civil defense and claims can be used by rights holders to the appropriate channels effectively enforced. These include in particular the granting of adequate information civil claims against the Internet service providers is required. The Ministers of Justice and Minister of Justice asking the government to bring forward legislative proposals. "What exactly according to a veer policy initiative of the Ministers of Justice, according to a 2008 alone, already twice the amendment of the Copyright Act, both in" are professionals "were discussed as extreme imperfection, with a emerge rather not forthcoming third amendment in 2009, toward the center of uniform as yet which is scheduled to Determined is not due to the failure to plan, and the unification of different party positions by the events in NRW clearer.
well be summed up that of the text with a quote: " Especially in the area of file sharing, which threatened to choke us to us, the legislature can stand in the rain ." After all, it has now emerged that at least the rain also will continue to be relied upon.
0 comments:
Post a Comment